![symposium.gif - 4.0 K](symposium.gif)
![Bear4.gif - 2.6 K](Bear4.gif)
Commentators:
David Sobel (guest editor), Bowling Green State University, Posted 4/8/99
Richard Arneson, University of California, San Diego, Posted 4/8/99
Thomas Christiano, University of Arizona, Posted 7/22/99
Reply: Elizabeth Anderson, University of Michigan, Posted 12/22/99