Divers led by Brown marine biologist discover surprising changes to offshore kelp forest

A research trip to a biodiversity hotspot in the Gulf of Maine underscores the importance of continued monitoring of marine ecosystems.

PROVIDENCE, R.I. [Brown University] — For nearly half a century, Brown University marine biologist Jon Witman has been diving Cashes Ledge, an underwater mountain range in the center of the Gulf of Maine that is home to one of the largest kelp forests on the East Coast. 

Witman has made more than 20 trips to the area, located 80 miles offshore, as part of a long-term monitoring effort to observe how climate change is affecting the kelp forest community of Cashes Ledge, and every time, the team discovers something new. An expedition earlier this summer offered a few encouraging surprises amid the widely observed decline of marine ecosystems. 

Cashes Ledge presents a unique opportunity to observe the effects of a warming ocean on not only different species of kelp but also on the innumerable fish, sea urchins, crustaceans, mollusks, invertebrates and other creatures that live in and subsist on the plants that flourishes along the 30-mile ridge.

“The reason we’re so focused on Cashes Ledge is that it’s exceptional — it has the most offshore biodiversity in the Gulf of Maine,” said Witman, who recently retired from teaching at Brown and became a professor emeritus of ecology, evolution and organismal biology. “It’s like a living museum of Gulf of Maine marine life.”

On the expedition in late June, Witman was joined by longtime collaborator Elizabeth Kintzing from the University of New Hampshire; Jennifer Adler, an underwater photographer who studied marine biology as an undergraduate at Brown; and Robert Lamb, who earned a Ph.D. in biology from Brown in 2019 and is now a research assistant professor at the University of Florida.

Because of storms and seven-foot waves, the team was only able to dive for one day, which was barely enough time to measure kelp plants, collect specimens and census fish populations, Witman said. Near the surface of the water, the team saw 20-foot basking sharks, giant ocean sunfish and fulmars, tube-nosed seabirds that are more typical of northern seas like the Canadian Arctic. Deeper under the water, they dove among goosefish, pollock and dogfish sharks.

To the team’s surprise, the kelp forest looked better than it did two years ago: while the number of plants appeared to have slightly decreased, the mass and volume seemed to have increased, which Witman said is an indication of sustained productivity. (Lab analyses will quantify the team’s observations.) Lamb found that fish, especially cunner and pollock, were abundant in the kelp forest.

Monitoring marine ecosystems

 

A video by Jon Witman from a dive in June 2025 shows the state of the kelp forest in Cashes Ledge plus curious cunner fish and invasive red algae.

During an expedition in June 2023, the dive team noticed a decline in the tall sugar kelp (Saccharina latissima) and worried it was being displaced by Laminaria digitata, a species of shorter kelp that tends to fare better at higher temperatures. While there does seem to be some indication of that happening, Witman said the number of both species of kelp “are pretty decent.” 

“The numbers of sugar kelp are certainly lower than they were when we first started censusing the kelp forest in 1987, but the pace of change has been slow,” Witman said. “By monitoring the area over time, we have seen that while it has been altered from its original state by heat waves, the forest is showing some resilience to some of the effects of human-caused climate change. And that is encouraging.”

A less encouraging observation was the spread of invasive red algae.

“There is some evidence from scientists at the Bigelow Lab in Maine that this red algal carpet is chemically altering the community of the ocean floor to make it less suitable for kelp,” Witman said. “Research trips allow us to keep our eye on the algae and to observe the slow yet significant changes that happen to the area over time.”

Due in part to the efforts of Witman’s team, the New England Fishery Management Council recognized the importance of Cashes Ledge by designating it a “Habitat Area of Special Concern.” Last year, Witman led of a group of scientists to submit a proposal along with the Conservation Law Foundation to ask the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration to consider Cashes Ledge as a national marine sanctuary, which would offer permanent protection from destructive commercial activities. The proposal was accepted and is under review, Witman said.

In the meantime, he and other researchers will continue to monitor the area.

“The Gulf of Maine is warming faster than 99% of the world’s oceans,” Witman said. “It’s really important to keep taking the pulse of marine ecosystems in this era of shockingly rapid change.”